Birmingham 205-324-4008

Alexander City 256-329-2000
MHH Law

The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Federal Circuit Affirms United States District Court Settlement in Carter vs Forjas Taurus, S.A., Taurus International Manufacturing, Inc.

BIRMINGHAM, Ala., July 6, 2017 /PRNewswire/ — On June 29, 2017, The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the Miami Federal District Court’s approval of a class-action settlement. The settlement is the result of a class action suit filed by Chris Carter against Taurus International Manufacturing, Inc., Forjas Taurus, S.A. and Taurus Holdings, Inc., alleging that nine Taurus handgun models had certain safety defects. Three class members, out of almost 1 million owners, opposed the settlement, but the District Court dismissed their objections and approved the Settlement.

In 2013, Carter was a Deputy with the Scott County, Iowa Sheriff’s Department. He owned a Taurus PT140 Millennium PRO pistol. While making an arrest, Carter’s gun fell from its holster and fired when it hit the ground. While no one was injured, Carter says the manual safety was engaged when his gun fell, and it was still engaged when he retrieved it from the ground. When engaged, the manual safety is supposed to prevent the gun from firing. Carter filed an individual lawsuit against Taurus on behalf of himself and a nationwide class of people who own certain Taurus gun models, alleging that the safety devices on the firearm were defective. Carter was represented by Todd Wheeles of Morris Haynes and David Selby of Bailey & Glasser, who were the leading lawyers of the class action suit.

The settlement agreement covers a nationwide class of gun owners, who own one or more of the following models, PT 24/7, PT111, PT111PRO, PT132, PT132PRO, PT138, PT138PRO, PT140, PT140PRO, PT145, PT145PRO, PT745, PT745PRO, PT609 and PT640.  The Settlement is valued at more than $30 million. Under the settlement, all class members can choose to turn in their class guns and receive one of two benefits: a cash payment of as much as $200 or an enhanced warranty, under which owners can exchange their guns for a similar new model that includes a trigger blade safety.

Troy Scheffler, Richard Jordan, and Steven Glaviano challenged the fairness of the settlement, miscalculation of attorney’s fees, the expert’s qualifications, and potential violation of the Second Amendment. After careful review, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals found the opposition’s challenges to the class settlement and the attorney’s fee award without merit.

Morris Haynes believes this is a positive development in gun safety. “This affirmance is another step towards higher standards for safety mechanisms and testing throughout the firearms industry. At the end of the day, we hope this settlement provides safer options for gun owners,” said Todd Wheeles of Morris Haynes Law.

Our case success stats

$3M
$3M
Settlement
Anonymous Plaintiff v. Anonymous Defendant
Attorney Larry Morris Pre-suit settlement of three million dollars wrongful death case
$2.5M
$2.5M
Settlement
Anonymous Plaintiff, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anonymous, deceased, v. Morrow Water Technologies, Inc., et al.
Randy Haynes Plaintiff’s husband was rear-ended by a pickup truck being operated by Defendant in the line and scope of his employment with Morrow Water Technologies, Inc., which also owned the vehicle. Plaintiff’s husband was died at the scene from the injuries he sustained in the collision. Plaintiff sued the Defendant driver and Morrow Water […]
$925k
$925k
Settlement
Anonymous Plaintiff v. Anonymous Defendant
Todd Wheeles In June, 2013, Plaintiff became sick with Legionnaire’s disease after being exposed to the bacteria in a hot tub at an apartment complex. Plaintiff filed suit against the owner of the apartment complex, the management company for the apartment complex, and the pool company responsible for the maintenance of the spa.
$250k
$250k
Settlement
Nettles v. USA
Todd Wheeles In February, 2014, a US Postal Service driver was making mail deliveries in Plaintiff Nettles’ neighborhood. The Defendant driver exited his vehicle to deliver mail to one of Plaintiff Nettles’ neighbors, returned to his delivery vehicle, put the vehicle in reverse, accelerated and struck Plaintiff Nettles with the vehicle’s rear bumper. Plaintiff Nettles […]
$250k
$250k
Settlement
Blevins v. Publix Super Markets, Inc.
Todd Wheeles In July, 2013, Plaintiff Blevins accompanied her daughter to a Publix Super Market in Birmingham, AL to pick up a few items her daughter needed for lunch and dinner. Plaintiff Blevins was walking through the deli department to join her daughter at the deli counter when she slipped and fell in an area […]
$58.2 M
$58.2 M
Verdict
Product Defect Case in TN
Daimler Chrysler sued for deaths caused by faulty designs and resulted in one of the largest verdicts ever in Shelby County.